Matt Judon Trade Grades: Falcons Get Veteran Pass Rusher; Patriots Boost Draft Capital

The NFL offseason is always a whirlwind of trades, signings, and strategic shifts, and the latest move has sent shockwaves through the league. The Atlanta Falcons have acquired star pass rusher Matt Judon from the New England Patriots in exchange for a 2025 third-round draft pick. This trade comes after Judon, a four-time Pro Bowl edge rusher, sought a new contract and ultimately held out at Patriots training camp. Let’s dive into the details and evaluate the impact of this trade on both teams.

Atlanta Falcons: A Strategic Move for Pass-Rushing Power

The Falcons have made a bold move by acquiring Matt Judon, aiming to fill a critical gap in their defensive line. Judon’s track record speaks volumes. Over the 2021 and 2022 seasons, he recorded 28.0 sacks, tying for the third-most in the NFL. Only the likes of Nick Bosa and Myles Garrett have had more during this period. However, the trade comes with its own set of challenges and questions.

Aging Star with Injury Concerns

At 32 years old, Judon brings a wealth of experience but also comes with concerns. He suffered a torn lower bicep in Week 4 of the 2023 season, sidelining him for the remainder of the year. This injury raises questions about his long-term durability and immediate impact. Additionally, Judon is entering the 2024 season without a new contract, which could lead to future complications.

Financial Flexibility and Future Prospects

To make room for Judon, the Falcons restructured the contract of star guard Chris Lindstrom, converting part of his base salary into a signing bonus. This maneuver creates cap space, potentially allowing the Falcons to negotiate a new deal with Judon if he performs well. Despite the uncertainty, the trade addresses Atlanta’s glaring need for a pass-rusher. The Falcons’ quarterback pressure rate since 2021 is the worst in the NFL, and Judon’s addition could significantly improve this stat.

New England Patriots: Smart Rebuilding Strategy

For the Patriots, trading Judon is a clear indication of their rebuilding strategy. With a record of 4-13 in the previous season and a struggling offense, the Patriots are focused on building for the future rather than investing in an aging star.

Acquiring Draft Capital

By trading Judon for a 2025 third-round pick, the Patriots have added valuable draft capital to their arsenal. This move aligns with their strategy to stockpile picks and rebuild their roster. The Patriots’ new regime, led by head coach Jerod Mayo and executive vice president Eliot Wolf, is focusing on long-term success rather than short-term gains.

The Trade’s Impact on the Patriots’ Rebuilding Process

The Patriots’ grade for this trade reflects their strategic goals. While they didn’t secure a first- or second-round pick, getting a Day 2 pick for an aging player with injury concerns is a solid outcome. This draft capital will be crucial as the Patriots aim to build a competitive team around young talents like quarterback Drake Maye, whom they selected third overall in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Trade Grades: Analyzing the Winners and Losers

Atlanta Falcons: B-

The Falcons’ acquisition of Judon addresses a significant need on their defensive line. However, the trade’s grade is tempered by several factors. Judon’s age and injury history are concerns, and the lack of a new contract adds an element of risk. The Falcons have been seeking a dominant pass rusher since 2016, and while Judon could provide an immediate boost, the long-term value remains uncertain.

New England Patriots: B+

For the Patriots, the trade is a win in terms of rebuilding. They’ve acquired a valuable draft pick and avoided committing future resources to an aging player with recent injury issues. The move fits well within their strategy of accumulating draft capital and developing a new roster. While a first- or second-round pick would have been ideal, the trade still represents a positive step in the right direction.

Final Thoughts: A Trade with Implications for Both Sides

The Matt Judon trade is a fascinating move that highlights the contrasting strategies of two NFL teams. The Atlanta Falcons are taking a calculated risk to enhance their pass-rushing capabilities, while the New England Patriots are focusing on long-term growth and flexibility. As the 2024 NFL season unfolds, the impact of this trade will become clearer, but for now, it represents a significant shift for both franchises.

In the world of NFL trades, it’s not just about who won the deal, but how it fits into each team’s broader strategy. Both the Falcons and the Patriots have their reasons for making this move, and only time will tell how it shapes their respective futures.